Compare
AI receptionist vs part-time secretary: what each covers at your practice
AI receptionist vs part-time secretary is rarely a like-for-like swap, because the two cover different hours and different tasks. A part-time medical secretary employed by the practice handles telephone and in-person reception, appointment scheduling and patient administration during contracted working hours. Once those hours end, the line goes to voicemail or simply rings.
ClinicAll takes on the phone and nothing else. It picks up each incoming call you route to it and answers as your practice’s front desk. For each call it takes down who is ringing, their date of birth and what they need, then passes the request to your team. It does not greet anyone at the counter, sort the post or read a patient’s file.
This page lays the two side by side, using the medical secretary job profile published by Appel Médical, then looks at which practice each one suits and where a secretary remains the stronger choice. Voicemail, an outside answering service and the other ways of covering a practice phone are set out on the comparison hub.
Who each option is for
A part-time secretary makes sense when the practice needs a person in the building, not only a voice on the line. They welcome patients as they arrive, show them to the waiting room and keep the paperwork moving between appointments. Appel Médical’s job profile also has them scheduling directly in the practice software, with the real diary on screen while the patient is still talking.
That presence comes with a fixed cost from the first month. Service-Public.fr – Smic lists a full-time gross floor of 1867.02 €/month in France, before employer contributions and any collective-agreement minimum. CCSS Luxembourg – Salaire social minimum lists an unskilled full-time gross floor of 2771.33 €/month, before employer contributions and any skills supplement. A part-time contract pays a proportional share of whichever floor applies, in line with the hours it fixes.
The contract that sets the pay also sets the reach of your phone. Service-Public.fr explains how a part-time contract fixes the working hours and how they are spread across the week, and outside those hours nobody is at the desk. The afternoon your secretary does not work, the lunch break and the end of the day all need another arrangement.
ClinicAll is built for the practice whose phone rings while nobody is available to take it. It picks up over lunch, after your secretary’s last hour, on their days off, and while they are checking a patient in at the counter. It answers as the practice’s front desk. Should a caller want to know who is speaking, it introduces itself as the practice’s virtual receptionist and never claims to be a person.
Your practice software decides where an appointment request ends up. With the Mikrono integration, the appointment sits in your diary by the time the caller hangs up. With XEYEX, ClinicAll holds a slot and your team confirms it. Any other software means appointments come to your team as callback requests, never as entries in the diary, and someone there rings the patient back to settle the time.
On the days your secretary is in, ClinicAll does not get in their way. It transfers to the desk when it is staffed and a transfer line is configured; otherwise it takes a callback request. That request waits in the dashboard with the caller’s details and reason for calling. Whether your secretary prefers the live call or the written request is yours to settle together, and weighing a transfer against a callback sets out both sides.
Before choosing, it pays to know exactly which hours of your week go unanswered. The opening-hours coverage tool lays your opening times over the hours when patients phone, and the missed-calls calculator estimates what those gaps mean for your practice. Check your phone coverage with the reachability check. The pattern behind those peaks is set out in when patients phone their practice.
Side by side
| Feature | ClinicAll | Part-time secretary |
|---|---|---|
| Booking | ||
| Books in the practice software | Yes, where the practice software allows it | Yes |
| Reads real availability | Yes, where the practice software allows it | Yes |
| Call handling | ||
| Answers outside opening hours | Yes | No |
Not stated in the sources for Part-time secretary: Transfers to staff, Callback requests, Several languages, No medical advice, Call summaries, Dashboard, Hosted in the EU, GDPR processing agreement, French-speaking support, Keep your number, Free trial, No minimum term.
| Plan | Per month | Minutes included | Extra minute |
|---|---|---|---|
| CCSS Luxembourg – Salaire social minimum unskilled rate, gross per month full time since 1 June 2026; a general floor, before employer contributions and any skills supplement | €2,771.33 | Not stated | Not stated |
| Service-Public.fr – Smic gross per month full time (35 hours a week), page verified on 1 June 2026 (order of 22 May 2026); the legal floor in France, before employer contributions and any collective-agreement minimum | €1,867.02 | Not stated | Not stated |
Facts taken from the public pages of Appel Médical, verified on 29 September 2026. How we compare
Part-time secretary: when it is the better fit
Some of a secretary’s work happens away from the phone entirely, and no line can take it on. They greet the patient who walks in, check the forms at the counter and keep each administrative file in order from one visit to the next. If your practice needs someone physically present, ClinicAll does not fill that role.
A secretary can also rearrange the diary without handing anything back. A patient who wants an earlier slot gets a new time during the call, because the real availability is on screen in the practice software. ClinicAll works the other way round. It never moves or cancels an appointment itself: your team confirms.
That difference matters most when your phone is mainly reschedules and cancellations. A secretary closes those calls in a single conversation, while ClinicAll turns each one into a callback request for the team. A practice with a crowded diary and frequent changes may find that the secretary saves more phone time than ClinicAll does.
Your secretary can open a patient’s file while the caller waits. When someone rings about a letter to collect or a form they sent in, the answer comes from the record there and then. ClinicAll does not look up a patient’s record; it writes down the question and sends it to your team as a callback request.
Some calls need someone who knows the people on your list: an elderly patient who rings every week, an anxious parent, a situation no instruction foresaw. A secretary reads the person and adjusts. ClinicAll gives no medical advice and applies your emergency rules, and it does nothing beyond what you have configured.
Languages draw another clear line. French and English are verified on lines already in service, and we validate any other language on your line before go-live. A secretary who shares a language with part of your patient list answers those callers in it from day one. For practices in Luxembourg, running a desk for a three-language patient list looks at this in detail.
For many practices the choice is not one or the other. Where the secretary stays, ClinicAll takes the hours they are not contracted for and the calls that arrive while they are busy with a patient at the counter. For an outside service rather than a salaried post, see how a medical answering service compares with an AI receptionist. The guide to what an AI secretary does in a medical practice covers the rest of its scope.
Cost does not line up neatly either, since a salary and a service are priced differently. Set against a payslip, ClinicAll’s price arrives as a written quote, drawn up after a 30-minute call; how that quote is put together is on the pricing page. As for the term, it is set in the written quote, before go-live; every plan has a minimum term. The team that sets ClinicAll up and answers your questions afterwards works in French, from Luxembourg.
Questions
Can an AI receptionist replace a part-time secretary?
Not entirely. ClinicAll answers the phone, notes why the patient is calling and passes the request to your team, but it does not work the counter or open a patient’s record. You can use it during hours when your secretary is off or already helping someone at the desk.
Can the AI receptionist reschedule or cancel an appointment?
No. It never moves or cancels an appointment itself: your team confirms. A patient who wants another time leaves a callback request with their name and the reason, and your secretary deals with it in the practice software.
What happens to calls when the secretary is at the desk?
They can still reach the secretary. ClinicAll transfers to the desk when it is staffed and a transfer line is configured; otherwise it takes a callback request. Your team finds that request in the dashboard.
Does the AI receptionist tell callers it is not a person?
Yes, whenever a caller asks. It answers as the practice’s front desk and, if asked, says it is the practice’s virtual receptionist. It never claims to be a person.
How does the cost compare with a part-time secretary?
ClinicAll’s price is quoted in writing after a 30-minute call. A secretary costs at least the legal minimum wage in proportion to their hours, plus employer contributions. As for ClinicAll’s term, it is set in the written quote, before go-live; every plan has a minimum term.
See it answer a call for your practice
A 30-minute demo by video. We show the assistant live and look at how it would fit your practice, your software and your rules.
Book a demo