Compare
AI receptionist vs medical answering service: who answers, and when
The AI receptionist vs medical answering service question usually comes up on a crowded morning, when the line keeps ringing while your desk is checking patients in. Both options take the calls your team cannot reach in time. They differ in who picks up, during which hours, and how far each one is allowed into your diary.
A medical answering service, as this page uses the term, is a team of remote secretaries shared between several practices. They answer patient calls, manage appointments and relay messages within the hours agreed with each practice and following its instructions. Thelem, Cor-tel and Médical Connexion stand for the category here, and each is described from its own website.
ClinicAll is the AI receptionist on the other side of the table. It picks up on your practice’s own number, greets callers as your front desk and files a written summary with every callback request, in a dashboard your team reads when it has a moment. The sections below set out who each option suits, where a remote secretary keeps the edge, and what practices ask before choosing, using the same method as the other comparisons for medical practices.
Who each option is for
The first thing to check is when your patients actually call. An answering service covers the hours written into its agreement with you; for answers outside opening hours, the table shows “No”, based on Thelem’s page about the cost of a telephone medical secretary. The receptionist also takes evening, Saturday and lunchtime calls, and each one waits as a callback request when the desk reopens. To find your own gaps, the opening hours coverage tool marks the hours of your week that nobody answers today.
A remote secretary suits a practice that wants a person to run the diary for it during working hours. Cor-tel says it books in the practice’s software and reads its real availability, according to its home page and its pricing page. A diary full of late cancellations, swaps and patients asking for another day gains from that work being done live, by someone with access to the schedule.
The receptionist suits a practice whose calls come in bursts: at opening, after lunch or late in the afternoon. It also answers while the person at the counter is helping a patient. Every incoming call gets an answer while the line is open, and each conversation leaves a written record in the dashboard. Your team then works through the callback requests in its own order, with the name, the reason for calling and the contact details already noted.
Cor-tel’s secretaries book in your software themselves; with the receptionist, the result depends on which software that is. With Mikrono, the appointment is in your diary at the end of the call, and no one at the desk needs to approve it. With XEYEX, the receptionist holds a slot and your team confirms it.
Any other software turns appointments into callback requests rather than diary entries: the appointment request reaches your team, who call the patient back to confirm it. The page on the practice software the receptionist connects to shows where each one stands.
Neither option asks you to change the number printed on your letterhead. Cor-tel’s home page says the practice keeps its own number, and ClinicAll answers on yours as well, so patients dial what they have always dialled. What changes is who is on the other end once the call is forwarded.
Language is the next question for practices near a border or with an international patient list. The receptionist recognises which language each caller uses; French and English are verified on lines already in service, and we validate any other language on your line before go-live. On the answering service side, the source used for that row of the table, Cor-tel’s site, does not say which languages its secretaries speak on the phone.
Setting up either service means talking to people, not filling in a web form. For ClinicAll, the team that configures the receptionist before go-live, and fields your questions after it, works in French, from Luxembourg. If you are weighing a hire at the desk instead, the page on an AI receptionist or a part-time secretary asks the same question for a salaried post.
Side by side
| Feature | ClinicAll | Human medical answering service |
|---|---|---|
| Booking | ||
| Books in the practice software | Yes, where the practice software allows it | Yes |
| Reads real availability | Yes, where the practice software allows it | Yes |
| Call handling | ||
| Transfers to staff | Yes, when the desk is staffed | Yes |
| Callback requests | Yes | Yes |
| Answers outside opening hours | Yes | No |
| Several languages | French and English verified | Not stated |
| No medical advice | Yes | Not stated |
| Data and follow-up | ||
| Call summaries | Yes | Not stated |
| Dashboard | Yes | Yes |
| Hosted in the EU | Call log in Germany; voice and telephony processed in the US | Not stated |
| GDPR processing agreement | Yes | Not stated |
| Terms and support | ||
| French-speaking support | Yes | Yes |
| Keep your number | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | No | Not stated |
| No minimum term | No | Yes |
| Plan | Per month | Minutes included | Extra minute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thelem – Professionnels de santé base subscription excluding VAT, no calls included; calls billed on top on a custom rate card | €28 | Not stated | Not stated |
| Cor-tel – Forfait 20 appels 20 calls a month, excluding VAT | €49.99 | Not stated | Not stated |
| Médical Connexion – À l’unité €1.30 per call; monthly package and included volume not stated for this option; VAT not applicable according to the provider | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
Facts taken from the public pages of Thelem, Cor-tel and Médical Connexion, verified on 29 September 2026. How we compare
Human medical answering service: when it is the better fit
A remote secretary has the clear advantage when a call needs the diary changed on the spot. Managing appointments is part of what these providers describe, so a secretary with access to your software can move a patient to the following Thursday while they are still on the line. ClinicAll works differently. It never moves or cancels an appointment itself: your team confirms, which means a patient asking for another day gets a call back rather than an answer straight away.
A person also copes better when a call leaves the expected path. A call might come from an elderly patient or a relative, or combine a prescription query, a late arrival and a billing question. A secretary adjusts to each of these within your instructions. The receptionist follows the rules you set, gives no medical advice and applies your emergency rules, and anything outside them becomes a callback request for your team.
Some patients simply want a human voice, and an answering service gives them one from the first word. The receptionist greets callers as your front desk; a caller who asks who is speaking learns that it is the practice’s virtual receptionist. It never claims to be a person, so a patient who needs reassurance from someone real is better served by a secretary.
For a practice with a light call volume, paying by usage can make sense. Médical Connexion publishes a per-call option, Cor-tel a monthly package with a set number of calls, and Thelem a base subscription for health professionals with calls billed on top at a custom rate. The guide to what a medical answering service costs explains how to compare these models with each other.
Terms differ too. Thelem’s pricing page lists a plan with no minimum term. ClinicAll’s pricing FAQ answers ‘No’ to ‘a free trial’ and states: “It is set in the written quote, before go-live; every plan has a minimum term.” The price itself follows a 30-minute call and is set down in a written quote, as the ClinicAll pricing page explains.
On data, the table repeats what each website publishes. For ClinicAll, the call log is hosted in Germany, while the processing of voice and telephony takes place in the United States, and the security and GDPR page sets out that arrangement. The sources used for the answering services do not state where data is hosted or whether a GDPR processing agreement is offered, so ask the provider before you sign.
An answering service puts a call through to your team when it needs to, according to Thelem’s pricing page, which also lists a dashboard for following calls. The receptionist transfers to the desk when it is staffed and a transfer line is configured; otherwise it takes a callback request. Which of the two your desk should prefer, and when, is the subject of the guide to putting a call through or ringing back.
If most of your calls arrive during working hours and concern changes to the diary, a remote secretary covers that need directly. If they come outside those hours, or in waves nobody at the desk can absorb, the receptionist takes them. The missed calls calculator estimates what your line lets through today, before you decide.
Questions
What is the difference between an AI receptionist and a medical answering service?
A medical answering service puts a remote secretary on the line during the hours agreed with your practice, and that secretary can manage the diary directly. An AI receptionist such as ClinicAll answers on your own number, outside opening hours too, and passes a summary and a callback request to your team. It never moves or cancels an appointment itself: your team confirms.
Can an AI receptionist book appointments in the practice software?
It depends on the software. With Mikrono, the appointment is in your diary at the end of the call; with XEYEX, the receptionist holds a slot and your team confirms it. With any other software, the request reaches your team as a callback request, not as a diary entry.
Do patients know they are talking to an AI receptionist?
Yes, whenever they ask. The receptionist answers as your front desk and, when a caller asks who is speaking, says it is the practice's virtual receptionist. It never claims to be a person, whereas an answering service puts a human secretary on the line.
Can the AI receptionist put a caller through to the practice?
Only when two things are true. It transfers to the desk when it is staffed and a transfer line is configured; otherwise it takes a callback request. Outside opening hours, no call is put through, and anything that needs your team waits as a callback request.
How are medical answering services priced?
Each provider uses its own model. Thelem publishes a base subscription with calls billed on top at a custom rate, Cor-tel a monthly package with a set number of calls, and Médical Connexion a per-call price. ClinicAll’s price is set in a written quote, after a 30-minute call.
See it answer a call for your practice
A 30-minute demo by video. We show the assistant live and look at how it would fit your practice, your software and your rules.
Book a demo